THE INFLUENCER DILEMMA: WHY MANY CONTENT CREATORS MISS THE MARK ON MARKETING

• Great content alone doesn’t guarantee marketing success; aligning creative efforts with business goals is essential.
• Vanity metrics such as likes and shares are less meaningful than conversions, click-through rates, and ROI-focused data.
• Understanding where and why sales happen is critical for evaluating campaign ROI and improving marketing strategies.
• Brands and influencers can better position themselves for success by staying educated about data-driven marketing best practices.

Shift focus from creating viral content that chases the shiny object to creating results-driven content.

Like it or not, influencers have become…influential in modern marketing. They’ve turned their personal brands into lucrative businesses — informing their massive followings about other brands’ products and services. Part of the reason this model succeeds? Influencers work hard to build trust with their audience.

However, many brands are starting to notice a growing issue. Influencers excel at creating engaging content, but most lack a solid understanding of marketing fundamentals, performance measurements, attribution, and ultimately, what drives business growth. This gap can lead to disappointing campaign results and frustration for brands trying to achieve real ROI from their influencer partnerships.

Content Without Strategy = Wasted Partnerships

Influencers are content creators. It’s their bread and butter. They’ve built their platforms by making posts that resonate with their audiences — entertainment, pro-tips, adventures with their dog — whatever that special something is their audience digs.

However, creating great content doesn’t automatically translate into effective marketing. The problem arises when influencers approach brand partnerships the same way they approach their personal content. That is, following their regular posting status quo rather than a business goals-focused strategy.

Marketing requires more than just a creative eye. It demands an understanding of target audiences, buyer personas, and the nuances of the sales funnel.

For example, a beautifully curated Instagram post might generate likes and comments. That’s all well and good. But if it doesn’t drive traffic, conversions, or sales, it’s not doing its job: positively impacting the business that pays them.

Marketing requires more than just a creative eye.

The Metrics that Matter

Many influencers focus on vanity metrics like follower counts, likes, and shares to demonstrate their value. While these numbers can indicate engagement, they’re often poor indicators of a campaign’s success.

Brands care about metrics that tie directly to growth: click-through rates, conversions, customer acquisition costs, and lifetime value. Many influencers either don’t understand these metrics or don’t prioritize them.

For example, how many influencers can confidently discuss the difference between impressions and reach, or explain the significance of UTM (Urchin Tracking Module) tracking for campaign attribution?

Without this knowledge, it becomes difficult for influencers to demonstrate how their efforts contribute to a brand’s bottom line. And without that ability, partnering with that influencer was a waste of time and resources.

Attribution Means Linking Actions to Results

Attribution is one of the trickiest aspects of marketing, and it’s an area where many influencers fall short.

Brands need to understand how and why a campaign worked. Did a sale come from an influencer’s Instagram story or a YouTube video? Was it a direct purchase or part of a longer customer journey?

Without proper attribution, it’s nearly impossible to determine the return on investment.

The reality is, many influencers don’t know how to use tracking tools, set up affiliate links, or integrate their efforts with broader marketing strategies like email campaigns or retargeting ads. This lack of integration leaves brands in the dark about the true impact of their influencer partnerships.

So…What Drives Business Growth?

The biggest misconception among influencers is that exposure alone is enough. While awareness is undoubtedly valuable, it’s only one piece of the puzzle.

Real business growth comes from a combination of awareness, consideration, and conversion. Influencers who fail to move their audiences through these stages of the sales funnel aren’t delivering the full value brands need.

Real business growth comes from a combination of awareness, consideration, and conversion.

The Solution: Education and Collaboration

For influencers to help businesses grow, they need to shift their focus from creating viral content that chases the shiny object to creating results-driven content.

This means:

1. Understanding the Brand’s Goals: Whether it’s driving sales, increasing app downloads, or growing an email list, influencers need to align their strategies with specific objectives.
2. Collaborating on Campaign Strategies: Influencers should work closely with brands to understand their target audience, messaging, and overall marketing strategy.
3. Using Data to Drive Decisions: Influencers must familiarize themselves with tools and platforms that provide actionable insights, such as Google Analytics, UTM tracking, and social media analytics dashboards.
4. Focusing on Long-Term Partnerships: One-off collaborations often fail to generate meaningful results. Building long-term relationships allows influencers to better understand a brand’s audience and consistently deliver value.

You’ve gotta prime partnerships for success.

The gap between influencers and effective marketing isn’t insurmountable. With proper education and training, influencers can learn the skills needed to better serve brands. Brands can also take a more active role in educating their influencer partners to provide them with the tools and resources to succeed.

Ultimately, the most successful influencer-brand partnerships will be those that prioritize collaboration, transparency, and a shared commitment to achieving measurable results. Influencers who invest in understanding marketing fundamentals will not only stand out in a crowded field but will also build more trust and profitability with their brand partners.

As the influencer marketing space continues to evolve, the key to growth isn’t just content creation; it’s a strategic approach that ties creativity to results. When influencers and brands get this balance right, everyone wins!

Ready to Level Up Your Influencer Marketing?

If you’re a brand seeking to create meaningful, results-driven influencer partnerships or an influencer looking to enhance your marketing skills, Sōsh can help. At Sōsh, we specialize in bridging the gap between content creation and effective marketing strategies.

Let’s collaborate to create campaigns that don’t just look good but also deliver measurable growth. Reach out to us today to learn how we can elevate your marketing efforts together.

Book A Chat with Sōsh

About Us

Founded in 1999, Sōsh is a Milwaukee-based creative marketing and advertising agency specializing in data-driven strategies for small to large brands. Sōsh focuses on a wide range of disciplines such as creative services, social media, digital marketing, web design, advertising, and our trademark events. Sōsh creates meaningful connections between brands and their audience and does so through strategic communication, captivating creative, and thoughtful engagement. We are a collection of strategists and creatives dedicated to adding value to both our client’s brands and their consumers’ lives.

If you’d like to explore more content like this, visit our website for additional insights and inspiration!